Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Blog 5: The Spiritual Significance of Book Burning


Source:
Roth, Joseph. “The Auto-Da-Fé of the Mind.” Sources of European History Since 1900. Ed. Marvin Perry, Matthew Berg, and James Krukones. Boston: Wadsworth, 2011. 165-167. Print.

Summary:

In this piece, Jewish writer Roth comments on the meaning of the Nazi book burnings.   He says, “The European mind is capitulating.”   The German Jewish writers, like him, have been defeated.  “We are proud of our defeat,” he declares, and is thankful that Jewish writers “are, thank God, safe from any temptation to take the side of the barbarians in any way.”  Then, interestingly, Roth places those Jewish writers on the side of Christendom as well as Judaism.

My Opinion:

I found this piece illuminating.  It caused me to ponder the spiritual significance of book burning to Western culture, and perhaps humanity.  Book burning is associated with fanaticism in our minds.  I wonder how much of the tragedy of book burning is the loss itself of the books versus the symbolism behind it—an assault on ideas and the freedom to express them.  To our culture, the books on the pyre could be ones that we detest, and yet we would still find it tragic.  Surely other copies of the books themselves exist—the words themselves are not being blotted out of existence.  This leads me to think that it is the symbolic and spiritual significance of book burning that resonates rather than something literal. 

It is because of the spiritual nature of book burning—its attack on intellect and conviction—that Roth could rightly claim that he and the other authors whose works were burned were part of “the noble ranks of the European army,” and “the only legitimate German representatives of that culture,” because they stood for liberty of conscience.  Their works were burned because they did not compromise with Nazi philosophy, preferring symbolic death over life as a sellout.  He proclaims, “God himself—and we are proud of the fact—will not allow us to betray Europe, Christendom, and Judaism.  God is with the vanquished, not with the victors!”   

He also claims that “[b]y destroying Jews they are persecuting Christ.  For the first time the Jews are not being murdered for crucifying Christ but for having produced him from their midst.  If the books of Jewish or supposed Jewish authors are burned, what is really set fire to is the Book of Books: the Bible.”  I’d like to explore this claim a little.  What is Roth’s basis for essentially equating Judaism and Christianity?  Certainly in the eyes of his opponents this is an audacious remark.  But it leads me to consider: what is the spirit of Christianity, Judaism, and European culture?  Here a couple of quotes might be illuminating. 

The first is from Jürgen Habermas, a modern German philosopher: “Egalitarian universalism, from which sprang the ideas of freedom and social solidarity, of an autonomous conduct of life and emancipation, of the individual morality of conscience, human rights and democracy, is the direct heir to the Judaic ethic of justice and the Christian ethic of love.” 

The second is from Gorman Beauchamp: “Liberals have felt free to advocate elimination of ‘repressive’ external restraints precisely because they still live in a social sphere created and conditioned by Judeo-Christian moral values, whose chastening custom and habit they expect to be internalized … For how many post-Christian generations can it endure? […] We are like the heirs to a great fortune, but one that has stopped growing: we live on the principle of that fortune which with each generation grows smaller and smaller.  At some point bankruptcy, inevitably, looms.” 

According to these men, the spirit of Christianity and Judaism has nurtured our sense of justice, equality, and morality.  Certainly these values were burned along with the books without a trial.  Without these values, the Western culture could not continue—it would bankrupt as Beauchamp said.  There are many differences between Judaism and Christianity, but for Joseph Roth, and for me as well, the spiritual tragedy of book burning makes differing religions into brothers threatened by a common enemy, fearlessly defending an entire culture.

Monday, June 18, 2012

Blog 4: The Antichrist


Source:
Nietzsche, Friedrich. “The Antichrist.” Sources of European History Since 1900. Ed. Marvin Perry, Matthew Berg, and James Krukones. Boston: Wadsworth, 2011. 36-37. Print.

Summary:

Nietzsche begins by defining good, bad and happiness: good is “all that heightens the feeling of power”; bad, “all that proceeds from weakness”; and happiness, “the feeling that power increases”.  He condemns contentment, peace, and virtue, and declares that we should help the weak and ill-constituted to perish.  Then he starts on Christianity, calling it “more harmful than any vice.” He calls the Christian “the domestic animal, the herd animal, the sick animal.” He accuses Christianity of waging war on the higher type of man and against “every feeling of reverence and distance between man and man.”  He insists that the Christian conception of God had “degenerated to the contradiction of life,” calling God “nothingness deified, the will to nothingness sanctified.” Nietzsche laments, “No one any longer possesses today the courage to claim special privileges or the right to rule, the courage to feel a sense of reverence towards himself and towards his equals—the courage for a pathos of distance… Our politics is morbid from this lack of courage!”  He seems to be in favor of “the aristocratic outlook,” which he says has been “undermined most deeply by the lie of equality of souls.”  At the same time, he seems to also be in favor of revolutions, and deplores the “Christian value judgment which translates every revolution into mere blood and crime.”  Christianity, Nietzsche seems to think, is the wrong type of revolution: “Christianity is a revolt of everything that crawls along the ground directed against that which is elevated: the Gospel of the “lowly” makes low.”

My Opinion:

Obviously I don’t agree with what Nietzsche is saying.  But I find this piece fascinating.  Nietzsche clearly was passionate about what he was writing.  He can’t have had very many adherents to his worldview, and his writing is not representative of any great social movement—just an ideological one.  It is interesting to wonder how Nietzsche would have viewed Hitler and the Nazi regime and World War II.  I think he would have praised Hitler as being “good,” according to Nietzsche’s definition that the piece started with.  But how would he have viewed the end of the war?  Why, in his hypothetical opinion, did it end as it did?  Hitler’s personality represented the type of overman that Nietzsche often praised, but he ultimately lost the war, and committed suicide.  Does this mean that Hitler was not as “good” as it seemed at the height of his career?  Were the Allies stronger, and thus better?  Or had Christianity’s “lie of the equality of souls” ultimately undermined something truly great?  I wonder if Nietzsche’s point of view was only valid because it was hypothetical.  Tyrants, Nietzsche’s “more valuable type”, come along, but they also, inevitably, are toppled, and often not by a new stronger man, but by the people at large.  Nietzsche would have them continue forever, or be replaced by someone stronger, but this necessitates them being surrounded by very weak people, who will allow it, which type of person Nietzsche sneered at.  What, then, was his goal? Anarchy?  A system like the earlier Germany with hundreds of independent kingdoms, thus allowing for hundreds of overmen? 

Nietzsche’s treatment of Christianity is, I think, incomplete.  He neglects, for example, how Christianity was (and still is) often used to justify the subjugation, even domination, of others.  Certainly that aspect of Christianity supports what Nietzsche would call “good.”  He also is, I think, too generous in equating Christianity with “the doctrine ‘equal rights for all’”.  This is an ideal that rarely is supported in actuality by the actions of Christians, especially not at the time that Nietzsche was writing, when it was very common for Christians to be extremely racist.  This may sound rather odd coming from someone who is Christian.  I feel that Christianity, in itself, is a very good thing, but that people’s interpretation of Christianity has, at many times in its history, been used to support Nietzsche’s overman just as often as it has embraced the “lowly”.

Monday, June 11, 2012

Blog 3: Against Social Change


Martin Luther’s “Admonition to Peace: A Reply to the Twelve Articles” (April 1525), and Martin Luther’s “Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants” (May 1525), pgs 106-113 and 130-134 of The German Reformation and the Peasant’s War: A Brief History With Documents by Michael G. Baylor

Summary:

In Luther’s earlier “Admonition to Peace,” he wrote to the “princes and lords” and to the peasants separately.  To the princes and lords, he basically condemned them for their injustices toward the peasants, and placed the blame for the rebellion squarely on their shoulders (and off of his own).  He recommended kindness towards the peasants.  The peasants Luther also condemns, criticizing their use of the sword, as well as “trying to give [their] unevangelical and un-Christian enterprise an evangelical appearance” (page 111).  He advised the peasants and lords to “arbitrate and settle this dispute amicably” (page 113). 

On the other hand, in Luther’s “Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants”, he pulled out all the stops.  He condemned the peasants for three main sins, asserting that each alone was worthy of death: breaking their oaths of obedience to their rulers, starting a rebellion, and blaspheming Christ by calling their cause a Christian enterprise.  Luther then proceeded to recommend that the uprising peasants be killed without mercy, saying, “This is the time of the sword, not the day of grace” (page 133), assuring the lords that theirs was the side of heaven!

My Opinion:

In his “Admonition to Peace,” Luther talks about the social injustices of the lords and princes, but his only recommendation for combating them is for the peasants and the lords to discuss it peacefully and come to a mutually beneficial solution. What he does not address is the fact that the nobility would never have considered any kind of solution (or even acknowledged a problem) had not there first been some sort of conflict.  Luther seems to pay lip service to the existence of social problem without being in favor of any kind of social change.  He makes this even more clear in “Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants,” claiming that God is on the side of the status quo, and that justice should be swift and harsh to those who rebel.  From these pieces, I gather that Luther was not the rebel that his opponents labeled him as, or even quite the pioneer I thought he was.  Certainly, Luther’s opinions must be viewed in light of the time in which he was born—well before revolutions like those in England, America and France that so shape our mindset of “inalienable rights” today.  In the minds of Luther and most of his contemporaries, “everybody” did things in the feudal system they were used to—and that must be for a reason.  It must be ordained by God.  At this time, the idea of taking destiny into one’s own hands and trying to change the world would have been considered heretical, even diabolical.  God, and God alone, would ordain and dictate change.  It’s still very hard for me to read what Luther wrote, though.  It was quite bloodthirsty at times.  Don’t get me wrong, Luther’s teachings and writings were very important, and did sow seeds that would prepare Europe for later social movements.  But he certainly was not ahead of his time when it comes to social change.

Friday, June 8, 2012

Blog 2: Message and Medium


“The Catholic Dilemma,” Chapter 3 of Printing, Propaganda, and Martin Luther, by Mark U. Edwards, Jr. pgs 57-82.

Summary:

This chapter talks about the disadvantages faced by Catholic supporters in responding to Luther and his supporters.  Edwards’s main argument is “both the medium and the message favored the Evangelical position” (57). He discusses how vernacular pamphlets can be bought and accessed (either by reading it or having it read to them) by anyone and encouraged lay involvement.  This was an advantage for Luther, but for his opponents “the Catholic pamphlets did what they argued should not be done” (58), i.e. they granted the public access to debates the Catholic church felt should be privately discussed among the clergy.  Additionally, in order to rebut Luther’s arguments, his opponents had to first restate them.  This meant that by publishing rebuttals they were actually helping spread the Reformist message!  Edwards also discusses how Murner, one of Luther’s greatest opponents, confused some of Luther’s arguments as he restated them.  Whether this was done inadvertently or willfully cannot be determined.  Edwards noted, “Catholic publicists could propagate ideas they deplored in the mistaken belief that that which repelled them would repel others” (73-74).  In the last part of the chapter, we learn that it “was not until the second half of the sixteenth century … that the institutional church began an organized effort to counter Evangelical controversial writing” (78).  Edwards gives several reasons for this lag of several decades:
·         The Church “thought mainly in terms of intervention by authorities,” not printing (78).
·         Catholics “were defending … an existing institution, whose faults and flaws were apparent,” while the Evangelicals were only defending ideals.  “It took some time for the Evangelicals to build their own imperfect institutions and thus become vulnerable to the criticism that reality differed significantly from the ideals they espoused” (79).
·         “Normally one does not even argue with outlaws… Further debate only gave apparent legitimacy to the Evangelical claim that there was something to debate” (79).
·         “Dissonance between the medium—hundreds of easily circulated pamphlets—and the message—common people should not discuss matters of faith since the discussions subverted proper authority—may have inhibited the Catholic response” (80).
·         “The Evangelical message was more easily propagated by the press than the Catholic message.  Evangelical emphasis on the word, and especially the word of Scripture, lent itself to written argument.   Catholicism, in contrast, was more ‘visually’ and ‘ritually’ oriented,” relying on the authority of tradition, which the Evangelicals did not accept (81).

My Opinion:

I chose this selection, because it is a point of view that I never considered before.  Particularly the ideas about how the medium can support or detract from the message are fascinating to me.  I’ve been thinking about other messages and how this idea ties in.  One example is today’s political messages.  Media today is fast, and emphasizes style over substance.  This type of medium lends itself really well to the sound bite and negative ads, but would actually detract from any kind of substantive policy descriptions, making them seem weak and less important, when in fact they are what the public actually needs in order to make informed decisions.  I think that this happened with the Catholic response to the Evangelicals—the medium weakened their arguments.  For them, they just had to concede the point a little as they began publishing.  What can we do in the political arena today?  The politicians’ answer has been to turn more and more to negative campaigning, sound bites, and staged photo opportunities.  Yet the more substantial messages need to be heard—we have a very uninformed public.  It seems that the only choice is to choose a different medium.  The problem is that there is not much of a market for a different medium.  In thinking about this example and reading this chapter, I really started to feel for the Catholic Church—their dilemma was much bigger than they probably realized at the time.  I also got a better understanding of why the Reformation really took off as it did, and how the printing press could have made such a big difference even in a mostly oral society.  The existence and availability of printed material, regardless of the words it contained, was a message all on its own—one that supported the cause of the Reformation.

I’d like to discuss another idea in this chapter that conflicts me a little.  This quote is Edwards summarizing Murner’s opinion: “Commoners could not separate the ‘sound and Christian’ from that which was ‘false and mixed with poison [and] also pungent with acidic comments.’  The ‘pious simple Christian’ did not understand how subtly falsehood is mixed with truth and the devilish angel transforms itself into the angel of light” (62).  I am very conflicted by this, because, honestly, I agree with Murner.  People are very gullible, easily distracted by media hype and misled by unfounded rumor and gossip.  Look at things like the “Y2K” crisis. Companies had to spend a lot of money on advertising that their clients were safe from the Y2K bogeyman because the public got so hyped up about a nonexistent problem.  And don’t get me started on all the crazy gossip about various public figures—and we just eat it all up, and aren’t even fazed when half of it turns out to not be true.  We’re still hungry for more.  In matters of religion, a lot of this happens as well.  There are so many completely different messages out there that a lot of people don’t know what to believe, so they often either believe everything or nothing.  On the other hand, I believe we do have a right to know, to think for ourselves, and to make informed decisions.  And I also believe in freedom of the press and am against government censorship.  I think the only way out of what Murner describes is education.  I think a lot of it needs to happen in the home—parents need to teach their children to sift through the mass of information available to us, and to distinguish truth from lies.  Teaching a healthy skepticism to your children probably seems counterintuitive to most parents because, like the Catholic church in Luther’s time, they don’t want “the way things are” and “because I said so” to be up for debate.  But with children being faced with decisions that can affect the rest of their lives at younger and younger ages, we need them to know how to think critically and sift the sound information from the falsehoods.  I don’t know how feasible that is, but it’s all we’ve got.